Jury weighing if circumstantial evidence is enough to convict man of 2020 murder

A jury is out to deliberate if a Lexington man accused of murder is guilty of suffocating Lexington lady Ava Creech and hiding her physique in a closet.

All events agree the evidence in opposition to 54-year-old William Parker “Bill” Brown is circumstantial — oblique evidence — however is it enough to convict him?

Assistant Commonwealth Attorney James Judge stated sure.

“Sometimes you don’t have all the pieces,” he stated. “But the question isn’t whether you have all the pieces; it is whether or not you can tell by looking all the pieces, that you can tell what happened.”

Brown is charged with murder, receiving stolen property and felon in possession of a handgun after he was arrested for the dying of 62-year-old Creech in September 2020.

Prosecutors stated Creech died September 11, 2020, however her physique wasn’t found by police until October 2 in her house closet. Creech had been certain with duct tape and with paper towels shoved down her throat.

Her trigger of dying was dominated as asphyxiation and blunt drive trauma.

During closing statements on Thursday morning, Judge offered a bulleted checklist and associated timeline which he stated confirms Brown’s guilt.

Brown was discovered with Creech’s capsules in his possession after her dying. Brown was driving Creech’s automobile. Prosecutors allege he tried to toss her keys within the woods and that he pawned Creech’s jewellery.

Judge stated the largest proof of guilt was duct tape that examined constructive for Creech’s blood and Brown’s DNA.

For Dan Parker, Brown’s legal professional, there have been “innocent explanations” to all of the prosecutors’ claims.

Parker stated Creech had a behavior of falling asleep smoking together with her house door open, so it was potential anybody might have come inside to hurt or assault her.

Regarding the duct tape, Parker stated Brown helped Creech field up her issues to put together for a mattress bug exterminator, which is how his DNA acquired on the roll.

Brown took the stand Wednesday afternoon and denied any involvement in Creech’s murder. His demeanor on the stand was calm, relaxed and conversational.

Not solely was there an abundance of harmless explanations, Parker stated, however there have been extra questions left than solutions, which solid a shadow of affordable doubt on the commonwealth’s claims.

Parker stated prosecutors witnesses had been unreliable, evidence wasn’t examined and different suspects weren’t investigated by police. One such instance was a hammer discovered on the scene that was in line with the trauma on Creech’s head. Police opted not to ship this evidence for testing.

“There are way more questions than answers,” Parker stated. “In this country when you are accused of a crime, it is not your job to prove your innocence.

”The job of doing the proving, is from those that do the accusing.”

Brown’s case started Monday. The jury started deliberating at 11 a.m. Thursday.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button