News

Jury finds security guard who shot, killed Alvin Motley guilty of second-degree murder

After days of witness testimony and reviewing the precise second of Alvin Motley Jr.’s loss of life, a Shelby County jury returned a guilty verdict within the second-degree murder trial of Gregory Livingston.

Livingston, a 57-year-old former contract security guard for Kroger, was arrested in September 2021 following the gasoline station taking pictures that killed Motley.

Motley was on the town along with his girlfriend, Pia Foster, from Chicago. The two have been to go to Motley’s members of the family and revel in a weekend about city. Motley suffered from Marfan syndrome, a dysfunction that limits the physique’s means to construct connective tissue. In Motley’s case, his eyesight was affected by the illness to the purpose of being legally blind.

The case was turned over to Nashville prosecutors after former Shelby County District Attorney Amy Weirich recused herself from the case, citing a battle of curiosity with the security firm Livingston was contracted with on the time of the taking pictures.

Alvin Motley Sr., the father of 48-year-old Alvin Motley who was allegedly shot and killed by Gregory Livingston, the guard at an East Memphis Kroger Fuel Center on August 7, is seen at Shelby County Criminal Court on Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2021.  Alvin Motley Sr., the father of 48-year-old Alvin Motley who was allegedly shot and killed by Gregory Livingston, the guard at an East Memphis Kroger Fuel Center on August 7, is seen at Shelby County Criminal Court on Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2021.

Alvin Motley Sr., the daddy of 48-year-old Alvin Motley who was allegedly shot and killed by Gregory Livingston, the guard at an East Memphis Kroger Fuel Center on August 7, is seen at Shelby County Criminal Court on Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2021.

Motley was on the gasoline station with Foster. The two have been listening to R&B music at a stage loud sufficient to attract Livingston’s consideration. Livingston started to yell at Motley and Foster to show their music down, and a back-and-forth argument shortly ensued between the three.

Foster, who had been pumping gasoline, had corralled an upset Motley again into her automotive and began to drive out of the gasoline station. Motley, in accordance with Foster, then started to exit the automobile once more, telling Foster he needed to go speak to Livingston “like men.”

Motley, holding a cigarette in a single hand and a beer in one other, casually walked in the direction of Livingston. The security guard will be heard saying, “Back up, back up.”

“Let’s talk about this like men,” was the very last thing an unarmed Motley stated earlier than Livingston took a taking pictures stance and fired one spherical point-blank into Motley’s chest. He died on the scene.

Organizers block gas pumps in protest of deadly shooting of Alvin Motley at the Kroger Fuel Center during the "Music for Motley" rally on Aug. 26, 2021, in East Memphis. A white security guard, is accused of shooting and killing Motley Jr., a 48-year-old Black man from Chicago, on August 7, at this Kroger Fuel Center.Organizers block gas pumps in protest of deadly shooting of Alvin Motley at the Kroger Fuel Center during the "Music for Motley" rally on Aug. 26, 2021, in East Memphis. A white security guard, is accused of shooting and killing Motley Jr., a 48-year-old Black man from Chicago, on August 7, at this Kroger Fuel Center.

Organizers block gasoline pumps in protest of lethal taking pictures of Alvin Motley on the Kroger Fuel Center through the “Music for Motley” rally on Aug. 26, 2021, in East Memphis. A white security guard, is accused of taking pictures and killing Motley Jr., a 48-year-old Black man from Chicago, on August 7, at this Kroger Fuel Center.

During the trial, there was no query about if Livingston had fired the deadly shot — it was caught on video, from a number of angles. Instead, Livingston’s protection sought to steer the jury that he had no manner of understanding what Motley meant to do as he walked towards him.

Witnesses from the gasoline station on the time of the taking pictures have been referred to as to the stand to recall the small print of how the argument escalated right into a deadly taking pictures.

Statements made by Foster or Motley through the argument like “You don’t know what kind of day we’re having,” or “I’ll kick your ass,” protection attorneys stated, may have been moderately interpreted as an intent to commit bodily hurt towards Livingston.

Prosecutors, in flip, pointed to proof of a gunshot wound by way of Motley’s proper wrist. Motley, they stated, was doubtless elevating his proper hand to his mouth to take a drag off of a cigarette when Livingston fired a shot at him.

Gregory Livingston, the guard who allegedly shot and killed 48-year-old Alvin Motley at an East Memphis Kroger Fuel Center on August 7, appeared at Shelby County Criminal Court on Monday, Aug. 16, 2021.Gregory Livingston, the guard who allegedly shot and killed 48-year-old Alvin Motley at an East Memphis Kroger Fuel Center on August 7, appeared at Shelby County Criminal Court on Monday, Aug. 16, 2021.

Gregory Livingston, the guard who allegedly shot and killed 48-year-old Alvin Motley at an East Memphis Kroger Fuel Center on August 7, appeared at Shelby County Criminal Court on Monday, Aug. 16, 2021.

Other indicators, like Livingston’s calm demeanor when speaking to a 911 operator or the truth that he circled Motley’s physique after the taking pictures “like a predator examining its kill” as an alternative of rendering assist painted a portrait of a person largely detached to the truth that he had simply shot and killed somebody, prosecutors stated.

“Everything about Livingston’s behavior and demeanor suggests he wasn’t at all alarmed,” stated Nashville Assistant District Attorney Ronald Dowdy.

Livingston will likely be sentenced at a later date. He faces at the least 15 and as much as 60 years in jail.

Micaela Watts is a reporter for The Commercial Appeal. She will be reached at [email protected].

This article initially appeared on Memphis Commercial Appeal: Jury finds man guilty of killing Alvin Motley at Memphis Kroger gas station

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button