How is Utah enforcing its new transgender bathroom law?

The signal for a girls’s bathroom on the Capitol in Salt Lake City is pictured on Tuesday, Jan. 16, 2024. (Photo by Spenser Heaps for Utah News Dispatch)

Utah’s public faculties, state companies and different publicly owned or managed services should now begin complying with Utah’s new regulation that restricts transgender people from accessing the bathrooms and locker rooms of the gender they identify with

While the regulation, HB257, took effect immediately when Gov. Spencer Cox signed it in January, sure provisions had a delayed efficient date to present authorities entities a couple of months to adjust to the regulation. On Wednesday, these measures took impact. 

Starting this week, the Utah State Auditor is now required to “receive and investigate alleged violations” of presidency entities not complying with the regulation. A new page on the Utah State Auditor’s complaint hotline website went live on Wednesday, the place Utahns can file complaints of presidency violations.

The Utah State Auditor is “limited to assessing a government entity’s compliance” with HB257, the auditor’s web site notes, and “does not review or make any determination on the actions of private individuals, nor does the State Auditor investigate or determine an individual’s sex or gender.”

The regulation requires authorities companies to contact regulation enforcement in the event that they obtain complaints or allegations about felony conduct in a “privacy space,” which incorporates going right into a sex-designated altering room that doesn’t correspond with their “biological sex,” in accordance with the invoice. 

“The alleged violation must have occurred at a publicly owned or controlled facility, program, or event,” the auditor’s web site states. “When possible, citizens should make a good faith effort to address and resolve concerns with the government entity before submitting a complaint to the State Auditor.”

If an auditor’s investigation substantiates a violation and if a authorities entity “fails to cure” it inside 30 days, the auditor might refer the violation to the Utah Attorney General’s Office, and the varsity or company might face a tremendous of as much as $10,000 per violation per day, in accordance with the invoice. 

Utah Auditor John Dougall advised Utah News Dispatch on Wednesday afternoon his workplace had not but obtained any official complaints. But given Utah’s authorities companies solely now are required to conform, time will inform whether or not his workplace will obtain any.

Allegations wouldn’t be made public until the auditor’s workplace investigates and particulars the findings in an audit report, Dougall stated. That’s a normal apply for a way his workplace handles complaints. 

How are faculties and college students responding?

In the weeks main as much as the May 1 efficient date for state companies, public faculties have been scrambling to organize college students and lecturers for the regulation’s necessities. 

Like most of the different 10 Republican-controlled states with similar bathroom restrictions, Utah’s rollout “has been roiled in confusion for Utah families amid a patchwork of plans that differ across districts,” the Associated Press reported

The Utah Legislature left it as much as particular person faculty districts to find out the right way to talk the invoice’s new restrictions and necessities. The regulation additionally requires faculties to create “privacy plans” for college kids uncomfortable with utilizing group loos.

“Boys must use the boys bathroom/locker room and girls must use the girls bathroom/locker room,” the invoice’s sponsor, Rep. Kera Birkeland, R-Morgan, posted on X forward of Wednesday’s deadline. “If for some reason that doesn’t work for a student, they need to use a single occupancy bathroom/locker room.” 

The state’s largest faculty districts (Granite, Alpine, Davis and Salt Lake City) advised the AP their principals have been skilled to deal with bathroom considerations on a person, case-by-case foundation with discretion and empathy for LGBTQ+ college students.

However, Graham Beeton, a Salt Lake City fifth grader who makes use of he/they pronouns, advised the AP the necessity to create a “privacy plan” with the varsity district will be isolating, and he doesn’t perceive why the federal government cares which bathroom he makes use of.

“It hurts me,” Beeton advised the AP. “I might be uncomfortable going into that restroom, so I want to go into a different one, but the law doesn’t say that I can.”

During the invoice’s debate on Capitol Hill, Birkeland and different Republican supporters argued it wasn’t meant to “target” transgender people. Rather, they stated it’s supposed to “protect” Utahns, particularly girls, from uncomfortable encounters whereas creating extra privateness areas for everybody. (The regulation additionally requires authorities companies to incorporate single occupant services in new building, in addition to take into account the feasibility of retrofitting or transforming present buildings to incorporate unisex bathroom services). 

Critics of the invoice, which included a handful of Republicans and all Democrats, argued it singles out transgender people, an already susceptible inhabitants, by forcing a lot of them to make use of services the place they don’t really feel protected or snug whereas portray them in a felony brush.

What does the regulation do?

HB257 contains no express penalties to punish a transgender individual for merely coming into a government-owned bathroom they establish with — until there are circumstances or conduct that trigger “affront or alarm.” Then they may face enhanced felony penalties in the event that they get charged with lewdness, trespassing, illegal loitering or voyeurism. 

The regulation, nonetheless, does make it against the law for an individual to easily enter a sex-designated altering room that doesn’t correspond with their “biological sex” and so they might additionally face elevated felony penalties for different crimes dedicated in that scenario. 


The invoice defines stand-alone loos individually from altering rooms, which embrace becoming rooms, locker rooms, communal bathe rooms and restrooms which can be connected to altering rooms, in accordance with a page Equality Utah and the ACLU of Utah created to deal with incessantly requested questions in regards to the advanced invoice. 

The regulation applies solely to public faculties and government-owned buildings, such because the Utah Capitol, and metropolis or county buildings. In Ok-12 public faculties, the regulation restricts entry to loos, altering rooms and locker rooms. In different government-owned services like nation recreation facilities or public universities, it solely explicitly restricts entry to sex-designated altering rooms. 

The regulation’s restrictions don’t apply to privately owned buildings. 

The regulation additionally contains exceptions: if an individual has legally amended their beginning certificates to correspond with the sex-designation of the altering room and has undergone a major intercourse attribute surgical process. 

Equality Utah and the American Civil Liberties Union of Utah identified on their truth sheet that HB257 doesn’t require Utahns to indicate documentation or paperwork to entry a bathroom or privateness house. However, additionally they famous the regulation requires authorities entities to contact regulation enforcement in response to complaints or allegations about felony conduct, which might embrace merely accessing a sex-designated altering room that doesn’t correspond with somebody’s “biological sex.” 

“Accordingly, people that others suspect ‘do not belong’ in a particular ‘privacy space’ might be subjected to interactions with law enforcement even when those spaces are not covered by the law,” Equality Utah and the ACLU of Utah’s truth sheet says, which included a hyperlink to resources to help Utahns know their rights when interacting with regulation enforcement. 

They additionally observe the regulation doesn’t embrace a measure for “individuals other than law enforcement officers to investigate or otherwise confront anyone for any purpose in relation to the bill’s prohibitions.”

“If you are confronted by someone other than law enforcement about your use of a restroom or changing room, we advise you to use your best judgment about how to react and stay safe given all of the circumstances in that situation,” Equality Utah and the ACLU of Utah stated. 

For extra solutions to incessantly requested questions, learn your entire FAQ sheet right here: 


The publish How is Utah enforcing its new transgender bathroom law? appeared first on Utah News Dispatch.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button